Skip to main content

New Accounting Standard-Setter for Private Companies

The parent organization of the Financial Accounting Standards Board will propose on Tuesday that a new body be set up to modify accounting rules for private companies, some of which have complained that existing rules are too complicated and costly.

The new group, to be called the Small Company Standards Improvement Council, would be able to modify or allow exceptions to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles, known as GAAP, for nonpublic companies.

The new group would be led by a member of FASB, and its meetings would include all seven members of the accounting standards board, said John J. Brennan, the chairman of the Financial Accounting Foundation, which appoints members of the accounting board. Decisions would be subject to ratification by FASB, which presumably would want to keep variations in standards to a minimum.

The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants has been leading a campaign for a separate standard-setter, and that was the proposal made in January by a panel whose members were chosen by the society, the foundation and state boards of accountancy. The foundation said that it rejected an entirely separate board out of concern that it would create a “little GAAP” for private companies and a “big GAAP” for public companies.

“The objective is to have GAAP be GAAP, with differences that will be almost inside baseball,” Mr. Brennan said in an interview. “The goal is when a banker looks at financial statements, they know that GAAP is GAAP.”

Under American law, public companies — those whose securities trade in public markets and are registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission — must follow GAAP. All other companies may use any system of accounting they choose. In practice, lenders are often willing to consider cash-flow statements or tax returns in making lending decisions.

One argument for different accounting rules is that those lenders can call the company and seek extra details, while public company investors are unlikely to be able to obtain additional information. Therefore, there may be less need for disclosures from private companies that can be expensive to compile.

Among the rules some private companies would like to have modified are those on fair value measurement, the impairment of good will, the consolidation of off-balance-sheet entities, disclosure of uncertain income tax benefits and accounting for stock options. It is expected that private companies that want to use the full GAAP could continue to do so.

In a speech in June, the chief accountant of the S.E.C., James Kroeker, cautioned against immediate action, saying that “in a number of areas additional research, study and outreach, particularly to investors, would be warranted prior to implementing any significant change in the standard-setting structure applicable to nonpublic entities.”

The S.E.C. has no direct authority in the area, but it would be able to decide whether a company that took advantage of private company exceptions to GAAP would have to redo its books when it filed to go public.

In a letter supporting the establishment of a separate board, William A. Pickert, an accountant in Wichita, Kan., said he had been “alarmed at the increasing frequency of the issuance of financial statements with GAAP departures. While once a very rare situation, this practice is becoming routine.” He said lenders would accept such statements because they understood some rules were overly burdensome.

The institute of accountants, in encouraging letters to support a separate standard-setter, argued that “history and the current environment clearly show that FASB cannot effectively balance the competing needs of both the public company and private company areas.” It added that “it does not make sense to incur significant cost to comply with standards that have become ever more irrelevant in the private company world.”

A dissenting panel member, Teri Yohn, said no evidence had been given “to suggest that there are sufficient differences between public companies and private companies to warrant different standards.” Ms. Yohn, a professor at Indiana University, added that “differential accounting standards for private companies will add significant complexity and cost to financial reporting.”

If different rules are adopted for private companies, an issue will arise of how investors should be informed when a company chooses to use the private rules. Teresa S. Polley, the chief executive of the Financial Accounting Foundation, said she did not think a different auditor’s letter would be necessary.

“They are following GAAP,” she said. “We don’t see the need for there to be any disclosure of an exception.”

The foundation said it would not adopt any changes until it considered public comments, which are due by Jan. 14.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Why Use a Book Keeping Service?

In the dog-eat-dog world of business that's evolved out of the recent economic crisis, more and more businesses are turning to a book keeping service as a way to more smoothly and accurately handle their financial legwork and free up key employees for other tasks. Especially for a growing company, errors and backlogs in book keeping can be disastrous. Companies need to have quick and accurate financial reports, especially in a climate where major decisions are being made nearly every day. These major decisions can mean survival or bankruptcy for many companies, and it's essential that they are being made with good information. In many companies, due to falling revenues, staff positions are being cut, and more work is being directed towards managers and in some cases, business owners. Individuals whose primary skills are leadership and financial management have found themselves spending untold hours logging data into financial systems, simply because the employees who previou...

Difference Between Financial and Managerial Accounting

Financial accounting reports are prepared for the use of external parties such as shareholders and creditors, whereas managerial accounting reports are prepared for managers inside the organization. This contrast in basic orientation results in a number of major differences between financial and managerial accounting, even though both financial and managerial accounting often rely on the same underlying financial data. In addition to the to the differences in who the reports are prepared for, financial and managerial accounting also differ in their emphasis between the past and the future, in the type of data provided to users, and in several other ways. These differences are discussed in the following paragraphs Emphasis on the Future: Since planning is such an important part of the manager's job, managerial accounting has a strong future orientation. In contrast, financial accounting primarily provides summaries of past financial transactions. These summaries may be useful in...

5 Things To Check when Hiring Bookkeeper Service

For all types of business, maintaining financial data is important. What's even more important is having someone who can do this work flawlessly. This is the reason why businesses continuously look out for the perfect bookkeeper service . With the appropriate bookkeeper service , business owners should be worry-free. Bookkeepers will handle the tasks relating to financial transactions including recording income and expenditure, drafting bank reconciliation statements, handling invoices, and managing payroll. All business owners know how important it is to have a bookkeeper. However, what most do not know is how to actually find a good one. First, it is important to evaluate potential bookkeepers in terms of training and educational background. Although bookkeepers are not necessarily required to have a degree in accounting, all must have had formal training in the field. You will most likely find individuals who have gone through some college coursework or have been certified...

Book Keeping Services by Tax King Inc

Some people don’t know the difference between accounting and  Book Keeping . I am from 10 years in this field. I know about it. Book Keeping is just recording the business transactions may be Excel file, Quick Books or any other accounting system. If we talk about Accounting, it is complete process start from invoices and end at the Financial Statements.  Here we are discussing the Book Keeping so we leave the accounting as it is. Tax King Inc is new in the market. It is not struggle of one person. We are team and working together from last 5-10 years.  All are Experts in Different account systems. It is my duty to mention here all account systems. We are working with Quick Books Pro, Quick Books Online, Myobe, Xero, Peachtree and Wave accounting system. If you need our services then contact us at  services@sixsensebusiness.com . We will provide you best services and you will take Next Step for your Business

The Hazards of Business Blogging

In order to cultivate a worthwhile online identity, business bloggers should hit the same strong points every time they publish content: write well, talk about the business, engage your readers, and stay on topic. However these simple guidelines often elude business bloggers who have little to no experience blogging. While it would be ideal for inexperienced writers to contract freelance writers or guest posters to generate great content, this is a luxury few can afford. Business bloggers would do well to pay attention to how and what they write in order to expand the reach of their enterprise. Great content can lead to great business, but it seems like the majority of business bloggers avoid this truth. Instead, the web is flooded with business blogs putting out weak content just for the sake of having something to show for their business online. Don’t be part of the bland majority; put some time into your business blog. Watch out for these unprofessional blogging habits as your eva...